AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for The Phoenix's Griffin

by Havetoist

schedule May 4, 2018 at 12:00 AM

Oh, I should have known better..... Really amazing work and now I need to sit somewhere and cry for awhile. But really, it was awesome.

person havetoist
schedule July 24, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Don't quite know where to begin--overwhelmed.....loved this story and love your writing. Very well plotted, couldn't put it down. Really evoked a lot of emotion in me and I have greatpectpect for the female heroine you've creatred.
~~~~~~
Marcia, thank for for liking Phaila.
~~~~~~
es mes me wonder if you write professionally. I'm going to recommend this to all my lotr fanfic friends. Thanks for a great story, and please add an epilogue to this one. Now, I'm off to read everything else you've got posted.
~~~~~~~
Not a professional writer, but only someone who has written stories for fun since she was a little girl.

This started out as a completely original story I was playing around with that morphed into this fanfiction. I never would have thought...I suppose the epiloge is in "The Pheonix and The Griffin", with ground work laid for the family quarrel in "The Feud of Shadow and Light". Again, all original characters. You will have to, however; wade through almost an entirely original character 'cast' and deal with much more story that does not involve Haldir. It will, eventually.
~~~~~~~

marcianightengale spw@pacbell.net 2004-07-21 id # 254578
Oh, since you're nice enough to respond to questions, maybe you'll help me understand what Phaila means when she says, "I would be a gentle ghost, Sheriff, not a tyrant...?" I don't get it and am sad not to understand.......
~~~~~
What she's trying to tell him is to remember her fondly, and not with anger, nor bitterness.

person marcianightengale
schedule July 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Oh, since you're nice enough to respond to questions, maybe you'll help me understand what Phaila means when she says, "I would be a gentle ghost, Sheriff, not a tyrant...?" I don't get it and am sad not to understand.......
person Anna
schedule March 12, 2004 at 12:00 AM
It's taken me two days to finish your story andd it is by far one of the best I've read. I became so enthralled with the characters, the language and the storyline, that I feld whd when it was over. I hope you write a sequel. I'm just starting "Amaras and Phaila". I'll bet I will enjoy it just as much. Thanks.
person Havetoist
schedule January 19, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Her last words to Haldir are "The heart is never neuatral."
person Jana
schedule January 17, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Quite possibly the best story I have ever read on FanFiction. What is the translation of the last words Phaila says to Haldir at the end of Chapter 18?
I hope you do add a prequel or sequel. This was marvelous!
person Chris
schedule January 16, 2004 at 12:00 AM
An absolutely enchanting story. I can hardly stop reading. I'm so pleased I caught your note about a re-write or I might have missed this. What a tremendous amount of effort this was (is).
person Havetoist
schedule January 12, 2004 at 12:00 AM
M ~

From Chapter 15 - Chapter 19. There was so much rewritten, new dialog, etc....the prior chapters, minor editing.....

T you you for reading.

person M
schedule January 10, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Hi, I am enjoying the story, but am a little confused. Which chaptere bee being changed? I see 19 chapters each time it is moved on the updated list, but have no way of knowing what is new or if you are just making minor edits. Could you please mark what is updated somehow so that i can go back and read the new part? Thanks!