AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for A Rose By Any Other Name

by Celesta

person yue
schedule February 9, 2004 at 12:00 AM
i love ur story. its soo sweet and heart warming. though i do think that the relationship is a bit too fast its still great. update soon.
person Sister Kitty
schedule February 9, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Yipeeeeeee
Ni
Nice start to the day - I wait with baited breath for the come-uppance of Haldir.
person Cait
schedule February 9, 2004 at 12:00 AM
OOO HEY!!!
So so so so so happy you updated. I was cracking up at the idea of Galadriel climbing the tree, then after she climbs down she simply just "glides away." LMAO!
This is such a great story. Don't let it be too long before you type up your next cha.lat.later
person xoulblade
schedule February 8, 2004 at 12:00 AM
LOL Too bad Hally doesnt end up with a black eye..............but he needs to get laid....OR a human girl can stumble (literally) on him, too bad Asca doesnt have a younger sister ooo *hinthint* (then he can get some) Like what his brothers told Leggy and Asca...okay I'll shut up but I love this chapter cant wait until the next one, Ja ne!
person xoulblade
schedule February 8, 2004 at 12:00 AM
LOL Too bad Hally doesnt end up with a black eye..............but he needs to get laid....OR a human girl can stumble (literally) on him, too bad Asca doesnt have a younger sister ooo *hinthint* (then he can get some) Like what his brothers told Leggy and Asca...okay I'll shut up but I love this chapter cant wait until the next one, Ja ne!
person xoulblade
schedule February 8, 2004 at 12:00 AM
LOL Too bad Hally doesnt end up with a black eye..............but he needs to get laid....OR a human girl can stumble (literally) on him, too bad Asca doesnt have a younger sister ooo *hinthint* (then he can get some) Like what his brothers told Leggy and Asca...okay I'll shut up but I love this chapter cant wait until the next one, Ja ne!
person xoulblade
schedule February 8, 2004 at 12:00 AM
AAACCKK!! please disregard the 2 EXTRA times I reviewed, but I guess that is a good thing!! anyway sorry about that......^_^
person tlstroud
schedule February 7, 2004 at 12:00 AM
I Love it, Love it, Love it. Please write more and soon.
person sisterkitty
schedule February 5, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Yippeee - a new installment

Please please let Haldir have a little bit more comeuppance - I want to see him grovel!!!!!!!

Thank you
person jw
schedule February 5, 2004 at 12:00 AM
LOL, Haldir got b#$%^ slapped and he got told where to stick it. I am wholeheartedly in agreement with Asca about the way Haldir's been acting. He really needs to be told how she was treated. IF he had been told after their first confrontation I doubt he would have treated that way. Also the way he spoke was not the way someone should treat a person of Royalty.

Please tell me that subtle hint that Galadriel gave Asca means that she’s pregnant. You know the following scene:


Ascadholiel’s eyebrows drew together a little in confusion at that statement. “Grow with me? But I’m through growing…”

Galadriel smiled mysteriously. “No on is ever truly finished growing, pen-neth (young one). Especially a woman. Now please, take the gift. I think it would look lovely on you.”>

I know that's what you mean isn't it, *cat-that-ate-the-canary-grin on face*. btw Thanks for the reply.